Ship Bottom Judge Orders Trial Over Dune Cutting



Ship Bottom Municipal Court Judge Daniel Sahin requested a day sure courtroom overall look at the conclusion of January for all get-togethers included in the scenario of the distinct-slicing of dunes at a new oceanfront design on 17th Street.  Legally, a date particular is the date actions are to be accomplished, according to the Regulation Dictionary. It is legally binding.  
Sahin claimed he would not hear any extra phone calls for adjournments in the matter, which was 1st right before his predecessor, Decide James Liguori, in January of this calendar year. Liguori retired about the summer season, and Sahin was appointed to get his position.  
“I’ve been right here a limited quantity of time, and I know it (the scenario) superior than my wife,” Sahin reported all through Monday’s court continuing.  
He dominated any dispositive movement be submitted two weeks prior to the get started of the January demo date, expressing the court administrator would operate with all the appropriate functions to be certain there are no calendar conflicts. A dispositive motion is made by an legal professional on behalf of a consumer that might finish all authorized proceedings ahead of that court, or just selected facets of the case.  
Sahin dominated soon after Curtis Dowell, lawyer for Hasim Sujak, the home owner, notified the court that he had “an in depth conversation” with Bonnie Peterson, municipal prosecutor, about the applicability of the ordinance at the coronary heart of the court docket proceedings.  
Sujak, Nathan Foote of Greenwood Tree Support and Michael Hertzberg of MMC Development Management were being all issued summonses for violating the borough’s seaside and dune upkeep rules.  
On Monday, Dowell briefly argued the actions that led to the reducing of dune vegetation and trees at his client’s house are not in line with the borough’s ordinance. He told the court he needed to send a letter looking for clarification.  
Whilst Hertzberg, who has elected to symbolize himself in the matter, did not remark, Amanda Wyatt, the lawyer for Foote, agreed.  
“There is some confusion,” she stated all through the Nov. 9 proceeding.  
Dowell claimed there are numerous difficulties, like the way the summonses ended up created, that are at concern. He mentioned the written summons was vague and did not consist of the full municipal code that the obvious-reducing violated.  
What are not imprecise are the penalties for any one convicted of violating the borough’s beach front and dune administration ordinance. Below Chapter 4, Area 8 of the borough’s municipal code, any man or woman, on conviction, may perhaps experience a wonderful of not extra than $2,000, imprisonment for a time period not to exceed 90 times or community assistance of not more than 90 times, or any blend of great, imprisonment and local community provider as established by the judge.   
The measure also mandates any person who permits the violation to continue could be issued different summonses for each working day the condition has not been remedied. By code, landowners whose home has been diminished by wave wash, wind or any other conditions that would cut down the beach front-dune program beneath the specifications established by the engineer’s base profile map are mandated to restore at their individual value and in accordance with the grades, slopes and contours as set forth in the foundation profile map and pursuant to the technical specs of the borough engineer.   
Under municipal code, dune restoration demands an application to be made that consists of a description of the actions to be performed, the equipment to be applied and any other facts the borough engineer deems required to appropriately review the proposed do the job. Restoration perform simply cannot start out right up until a allow has been issued by the borough. The do the job will have to then start in 10 days and be finished within just 30 times until if not authorized by the governing human body, according to municipal code.   
Need to the house operator fail to start or total the operate in the accepted time body, the borough has the right to complete the get the job done. The price will be assessed to the residence owner as a lien and levied as a tax on the land, less than municipal code. Restoration operate need to be concluded by May possibly 15 and can’t get started any earlier than Oct. 15 except permitted by the borough council.  
Due to the fact the scenario 1st appeared on the municipal court docket docket, the borough council acted at two consecutive council conferences to strengthen beach front and dune protection as a final result of the incident. At the council’s Feb. 25 assembly, the council unanimously passed Ordinance 02-2020 C soon after a community hearing that netted no community remark. The ordinance sets the utmost great for everyone violating or failing to comply with the borough’s seaside safety and bulkhead legislation at $2,000.  
— Gina G. Scala 
ggscala@thesandpaper.net 

Leave a Reply